EarnoReview
Costco

Costco Q4 Earnings Call Takeaways: Renewal Rate Ticks Up to 89.8%

Costco's fiscal fourth quarter brought $95.72 billion in revenue, higher renewal rates and record executive members, but paid membership growth slowed to 3.8%.

Sep 25, 20263 min read
Costco paid membership growth, fiscal 2026
Costco paid membership growth, fiscal 2026. Image: Earno Review chart (Original chart from public data)

The news

Costco Wholesale’s fiscal fourth-quarter report on Thursday, September 24, gave investors two stories at once. Revenue rose 11.1% to $95.72 billion, ahead of the $94.86 billion LSEG consensus, and adjusted earnings per share climbed 15% to $6.75 for the 16-week period. Those earnings call takeaways on membership, though, were mixed: renewal rates edged higher while the growth in paid members kept slowing.

Excluding a 15-cent benefit from tariff refunds, which followed the Supreme Court’s February ruling against the emergency tariffs, EPS still beat expectations. Membership fee income rose 7.3% to $1.85 billion, a little below the FactSet estimate of $1.86 billion. Shares closed Thursday at $896.48, down 18% from the May 19 closing high, and were little changed after hours.

Our analysis

The membership numbers are the center of the debate over the stock, and they point in different directions.

Membership metricFourth quarter
Worldwide renewal rate89.8% (89.7% prior)
U.S./Canada renewal rate92.3% (92.2% prior)
Paid members84.1 million (+3.8% y/y)
Executive members42.3 million, an all-time high

Paid-member growth has decelerated through fiscal 2026, from 5.2% in the first quarter to 4.8%, 4.1% and now 3.8%. Executive memberships, which cost $130 a year against $65 for the basic tier, hit a record 42.3 million. They typically renew at a higher rate, and CEO Ron Vachris said rising executive penetration should help renewal rates in the future.

Younger members and the digital channel

Management said the member base under 40 has grown nearly 60% since Covid and now makes up more than a quarter of the total. These members start out spending a little less and grow into higher spenders, Mr. Vachris said. The catch, as CFO Gary Millerchip described it, is that younger, digitally engaged members have been flowing through the published renewal rate and contributing to a normalization of membership growth. Mr. Millerchip said traffic to the website from AI search grew at triple digits for a second consecutive quarter and converts better than other traffic.

Total comparable sales rose 9.4%, with traffic up 3.3% and ticket up 5.9%. Strip out currency and gasoline and comps were up 6.7%, with ticket up only 3.3%. Digitally enabled comps rose 19.5%. Gross margin fell 11 basis points to 11.02% but was up 20 basis points excluding gas price inflation.

Gasoline and the digital channel

Mr. Vachris called gasoline a record business for the year, with the share of U.S. member households buying gas at an all-time high. He estimated members saved more than $3.2 billion against the average price at the pump in Costco’s markets. Gas earns little profit, but it brings members to the warehouse, where many buy other items. E-commerce site and app traffic rose 30%, which supports the 19.5% gain in digitally enabled comparable sales.

Room for disagreement

Bulls can point to record executive membership, record gasoline participation and rising renewals. Skeptics will note that headline comps benefited from gas prices and currency, that fee income missed slightly, and that paid-member growth slowed in each quarter of fiscal 2026. A renewal rate that moves by 0.1 percentage point is a small change to carry the argument for a premium valuation.

What to watch

Costco opened 12 warehouses in the quarter and 28 in fiscal 2026, and plans 28 more in fiscal 2027 along with five relocations, for a total of 939 locations today. Capital spending is guided to $7.5 billion in fiscal 2027, up from $6.4 billion, with growth in the spending pace slowing from 2028. The next signals are the renewal rate in the first quarter of fiscal 2027 and whether paid-member growth stabilizes near 4%.

Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.

Related